Championship Game Weekend

[ice grillin you]

lol old spice

[ice grillin you]

shane vereen should be white

[MDS]

if peyton wins another one does he pass elway

[SD]

No

[ice grillin you]

if peyton wins another one does he pass elway

as a bronco or as a qb?

hes already ten times the qb and will never truly be a bronco

[MDS]

as a qb

where does he rank if he wins another? he might top the all time list

[ice grillin you]

its so hard to judge qb's cause the league has changed so much over the decades

steve young will always be my goat....i laugh so hard at what hed do in todays nfl

but an all time list still needs to be in existence and if peyton wins another i think that puts him top 3

[SD]

Mike Miss ranked his top 5 all time on Friday and asked for feedback...they were
Elway
Montana
Brady
Manning
Favre

You can only go after 80 for the most part since the nfl has changed so much and none of us remember the qbs from the 70

A lot of people had a problem with Favre as I do. He had the numbers and a title but the last 10 years of his career were marred by choking in big moments. A few people thought Aikman should be #5...I just don't see it. Young was my pick as #5.

[MDS]

favre only won 1 and stopped giving a shtein around 2002...hes a pos

joe has always been my boy but if manning wins then i think hes gotta top the list

[ice grillin you]

farve was a much better qb than elway

forget football there might not be a more overrated athlete in sports history than john elway

[General_Failure]

I don't think much of Favre or Elway. I'd probably put Brees ahead of both of them.

Detmer
Manning
Montana
Brady
Marino
Young or Moon

[QB Eagles]

Peyton Manning is the best QB all-time and that's true even if he somehow loses this game. If you weight playoff outcomes more than I do, it's Montana or Brady.

I put Elway and Marino in the next tier down.

[ice grillin you]

jeff george has a higher career completion % than john elway

[SD]

My top two are Brady and Montana. Both could do it in the regular season and the post season. I give the edge to Brady because he's done more with less.

[General_Failure]

It isn't a really good sight to see a guy's arm hanging and shaking like that, but he's probably fine.