Who to start thread 2010

[Munson]

Both of my drafts left me with a lot of questions, and I know others here like hearing what the rest of CF has to say. God knows why.

So for team 1...
Devery Henderson vs. Vikings
or
Devin Aromashodu vs. Detroit

It's a PPR league

Team 2
Got a WR/RB flex position to fill between these guys:
Jahvid Best vs. Chicago
Ahmad Bradshaw vs. Carolina
Pierre Garcon vs. Houston
Robert Meachem vs. Vikings
Jabar Gaffney vs. Jacksonville

This league is not PPR

[rjs246]

Aromatherapy and Best.

[Munson]

I was leaning towards both. Thank you, rjs.

[Sgt PSN]

Shotgun and mouth. Do it.

[PhillyPhreak54]

Rashard Mendenhall or Matt Forte

Pick one of:

Jeremy Maclin
Demaryius Thomas
Braylon Edwards
Chris Chambers

[Munson]

Shotgun and mouth. Do it.

I'm not running Andy Reid's offense, thanks.


Phreak-That's tough. Is it PPR? Even with the down year last year Forte still had 50 catches. He looked good in preseason and while the falcons don't have the best D in the world, it's certainly better than Detroits....I'd go Forte.


As for the WR's, I'd go with Maclin. Thomas isn't starting over Gaffney and Royal, Edwards didn't look good in preseason and is in a run first O going against the Ravens D, and Chambers is old and despite being in the Chiefs offense he's still the 2nd option in the pass attack (Maybe even 3rd after Jamaal Charles)

[PhillyPhreak54]

PPR

I wonder about Mendenhall at the goal line and against ATL. I am leaning towards Forte & Maclin

[Munson]

hah, yeah I don't why I said Titans. But pretty much the same thing can be said about their D

[Sgt PSN]

Rashard Mendenhall or Matt Forte

Pick one of:

Jeremy Maclin
Demaryius Thomas
Braylon Edwards
Chris Chambers

Mendenhall.  You know the Steelers are going to try and run the ball to take pressure off Dixon.  And Forte has to run around Ndmoiadngioafgjkong. 

Chambers is a sleeper pick too.  After getting cut by the Chargers last year, Chambers had like 70-80 yds and a TD against them with the Chiefs.

[Munson]

.........farging Devery.

[phattymatty]

i would have said devery and bradshaw but too late now.

[Diomedes]

In our keeper I had to decide between Percy Harvin last night or Jerome Harrison on Sunday for the flex position.  I went with Harvin figuring he'd show up under the prime time lights of the season opener.

But I knew what was going to happen:  Harvin was going to beg off on account of a headache and Harrison is going to put up 200yds/2tds (which he will of course not come close to repeating again all season, no matter how many times I start him).

Harvin didn't have a headache, but he didn't really have a football game either.  So I'm on track.  Which is nice.

[Munson]

Made a trade to try and improve my WR core. Traded Best and Braylon Edwards for Donald Driver and Bradshaw. Pick two of these RB's, all of which have great farging matchups, in a PPR league

Steven Jackson vs. OAK
Jamaal Charles vs. CLE
Ahmad Bradshaw vs. IND
Brandon Jackson vs. BUF

And pick 2 of these WR's for the same league:
Donald Driver vs. BUF (probably picking him anyway)
Jabar Gaffney vs. SEA
Santana Moss vs. HOU
Devin Aromashodu vs. DAL
Devery Henderson vs. SF
Legedu Naanee vs. JAC

[SunMo]

i'm seriously considering sitting Moss and starting Maclin this week.  I'm afraid moss will get stuck on revis island.

[reese125]

toss up. could be a smokescreen by the Jets saying that Revis will blanket Moss all day. Last week, Revis only played the one side of the field all night and covered whoever was over there.

last game against the Jets, Welker had 15 catches for 190 yards. If they are smart, they put Revis on Welker, and use roll coverage on Moss on the outside.