Keeper Decision (Non-CF) Help

[Tomahawk]

I get to keep 3 out of this championship winning roster in a PPR starting 2 RBs and 3 WR:

QBs
McNabb
Thigpen

RBs
Westbrook
Pierre Thomas
Justin Fargas
Tim Hightower
Chester Taylor

WRs
Andre Johnson
Reggie Wayne
Steve Smith (CAR)
Devin Hester

The rest don't really matter.

My initial thought was Westbrook, Johnson, Smith

Does that sound right? Choosing between Smith and Wayne is almost a coinflip for me and I'm almost thinking I should keep Thomas over Westbrook

[4and26]

RB is a tough one for an Eagles fan!

I'd keep Wayne over Smith - just based on the QB.

[Diomedes]

Why not keep those three solid WRs and focus on drafting RB? 

Johnson
Wayne
Smith

[rjs246]

How in the farg did you win a championship with that team?

[Tomahawk]

Why not keep those three solid WRs and focus on drafting RB? 

Johnson
Wayne
Smith

I never even thought of doing that - warrants some consideration. Thanks.

How in the farg did you win a championship with that team?

Same way anybody wins a championship - luck

[Munson]

Probably cause it was PPR, and he had three beast WR's, and a couple RB's who caught some balls out of the backfield.