A Decade of Andy Reid

[ice grillin you]

lol @ mike caldwell being out giving you a 'bad feel'

[MDS]

looking back on its the insane the free pass mcnabb got for those losses

people blamed blaine bishop more for the tampa loss and pinkston for the carolina one

what was wrong with us

[Don Ho]

lol @ mike caldwell being out giving you a 'bad feel'

Major blunder, sorry.  I told you this subject caused me to drink.  I meant Carlos Emmons.  Remember he went down in that stupid OT loss to the niners late in the season.  The game were McNabb threw the int in OT.

[PhillyPhreak54]

looking back on its the insane the free pass mcnabb got for those losses

people blamed blaine bishop more for the tampa loss and pinkston for the carolina one

what was wrong with us

Your obsession is borderline clinical.

Do they have padded cells down in Brownsville? You're headed to one.

[MDS]

he is the george w. bush of eagles quarterbacks

[General_Failure]

When this sports writing thing falls apart on you, you've got a fine backup plan in political editorials.

[Drunkmasterflex]

I don't see how McNabb can be blamed for the Carolina loss.  The WRs got straight bitch slapped, not to mention McNabb took that cheap shot in the first half.

[PhillyPhreak54]

He can't. MDS is either fishing or retarded.

Todd is the GWB of CF

[QB Eagles]

I think the 2002 and 2004 teams were the best Eagles teams of the Reid era, so those playoff losses hurt the most.

The Bucs game hurt the worst because I still think the Eagles were better than the Bucs and Raiders, and they simply shat the bed. Prior to that game they had owned the Bucs for several years running. The 2004 Pats were legitimately a better team than the Eagles.

[Rome]

100 yards passing and 3 picks.  mcdouche gets the gas face.

[SunMo]

2004 was probably his biggest playoff failing, followed by 2002

[MDS]

he was the reason why they lost the super bowl. he was horrendous in that game and his goal line interception to harrison in the 1st qtr was maybe the worst pass in eagles history. changed the game.

2008 was more so a moment than the entire the game. it was first the mindset he had that once he threw the td to jackson the game was over. yes the defense came out and coughed up the lead but mcnabb at the point wanted nothing to do with the game anymore. in his mind he had done his part and if they lost it was on the defense, not him.

but that was a microcosm of his and the teams repeated failures over the past 10 years. some guys, like elway, can fail 3000 times but still be as great as they ever were. some guys, like mcnabb, can only fail so much and only receive so much heat and negativity before it begins to crumble their insides. 3 straight nfc title losses, a super bowl loss, the TO drama, the team doing better with garcia than him...all of that added up to him taking heat for the first time in his life and he obviously couldnt even remotely begin to handle it. 

[PhillyPhreak54]

(insert igy's didn't read icon here)

[Rome]

You didn't miss much but he's dead on about Donnie.

[PhillyPhreak54]

Equally shocking that you agree with him.