A Decade of Andy Reid

[Diomedes]

Some douchebag put together a 53 man "All Reid" team.  The essay contains blurbs on players, but if you want to skip that, here's their roster (minimun two years on an AR Eagles team required for consideration)

53 Man "All-Reid" era roster:

QB:  McNabb, Vick, Koy
RB: Westbrook, McCoy, Staley, Mitchell
FB: Martin
WR:  Jackson, Owens, Maclin, Curtis, Brown
TE: Celek, Lewis, Smith

LT  Thomas
LG Herremans
C Jackson
RG Mayberry
RT  Runyan

Backup OL: Peters, Welbourn, Fraley, Andrews

K Akers
P Landeta
LS  Bartrum

DE:  Cole, Douglas, Kearse, Babin, Parker, Howard
DT:  Simon, Walker, Patterson, Thomas

MLB  Trotter, Bradley
OLB Emmons, Caldwell, Jones, Reese

CB Vincent, Samuel, Taylor, Shepard, Brown

S Dawkins, Lewis, Mikell, Moore

---------------------------------------
I pretty much agree, but I'd keep He Flag Me as a sixth CB and drop Moore.  If a safety were needed, Brown could fill in.

[Sgt PSN]

Which Brown is he talking about at WR?  Reggie or Na?  Either way, I'd take Avant over both of them. So add Avant and Harris in place of Brown and Moore and its good.

I'd probably have Taylor over Assante on the depth chart too. Not as many ints but better overall coverage IMO. Tackling is a wash between the 2.

[ice grillin you]

chad lewis over celek
sheldon over asante

[Munson]

Celek is making a case to be better than Lewis....Vick just has to find him more.

Hell, he's definitely gotta be better in YAC....he's a bull, Lewis was always doing the stop drop and roll fire drill..

[SunMo]

those linebackers make me want to throw up outside of emmons and trotter

[Rome]

sheldon over asante

pgbatsignal

[Sgt PSN]

those linebackers make me want to throw up outside of emmons and trotter

You could probably add Shawn Barber over Jones. I'd keep Reese.

[PhillyPhreak54]

those linebackers make me want to throw up outside of emmons and trotter

lol pretty much.

I'd keep Ike and I agree with taking He Flag Me over Damon Moore or Asante

[SunMo]

what about....THE BULLET!?

[General_Failure]

Eat it after seeing those linebackers.

[Feva]

those linebackers make me want to throw up outside of emmons and trotter

Word. When you're hanging your hat on Mike farging Caldwell... you don't have shtein at LB.

Also, skimming through it at first, I saw the backup OL before the starters and I almost called BS that Peters would be considered a backup, but then it hit me that's because of Tra... which makes sense.

[Sgt PSN]

The other thing is that healthy Andrews is starting over Mayberry every day. If you're going on talent alone, no way is he a backup.

[General_Failure]

If you're going on talent alone, Vick doesn't sit behind McNabb, Asante doesn't get left off for Sheldon, and Blaine Bishop gets a mention.

[Don Ho]

those linebackers make me want to throw up outside of emmons and trotter

You could probably add Shawn Barber over Jones. I'd keep Reese.

No doubt Barber belongs on there

Speaking of Barber, Sarge, where's that t-shirt?

[Seabiscuit36]

what about....THE BULLET!?

He's probably still trying to find his contacts.