2006 Free Agent Tracker - Offense

[rjs246]

I'd much rather have Garcia than Brooks. Have any of you actually watched the Saints play? He's awful. Talented, but dumb as a brick.

[PhillyGirl]

I'd much rather have Garcia than Brooks. Have any of you actually watched the Saints play? He's awful. Talented, but dumb as a brick.

I agree. I can't even believe there is discussion on this right now lol.

Not to mention, Garcia knows this offense.

[SunMo]

I'd much rather have Garcia than Brooks. Have any of you actually watched the Saints play? He's awful. Talented, but dumb as a brick.

that statement = 98.67% of the NFL

[PhillyPhreak54]

Dio ans GF are on the GET BROOKS!! wagon.

[ice grillin you]

id take brooks over garcia anyday...brooks got skills and was a victim of new orleans horrid coaching and even worse organization...

[PhillyPhreak54]

Brooks is horrible.

I'm OK with the Garcia move, but I had other guys who I would've preferred.

Bad coaching doesn't cause him to make some of the stupid ass throws that he has made. Remember than one against Denver where he threw it with his left hand? He's a moron.

[ice grillin you]

whats mcnabb then with his dallas and superbowl ints?

brooks isnt even close to as good as donovan but on a hideous team for so long with no confidence or coaching those things are going to happen

in a stable setting like the birds have as a back up not expected to do much i think hed thrive

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Brooks had a good OL, Joe Horn, Donte Stallworth, and Deuce McAllister, and he still regularly blew games.

McNabb was throwing an out route to a rookie receiver who ran a 'go' against Dallas.  In the Super Bowl, he far outperformed Roethlisberger's performance the next year, but Roethlisberger had a defense.

Brooks finds excuses to choke in non-pressure situations.  McNabb chokes under intense pressure when he's getting very little help from his defense and/or his receivers.

[ice grillin you]

mcnabb>brooks

brooks>garcia

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

McNabb >>> Garcia

Garcia > Brooks

Brooks > McMahon

McMahon > me

[PhillyGirl]

McMahon > me

me > McMahon

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Yeah, well... I have arthritis in my throwing shoulder.

[General_Failure]

I'd much rather have Garcia than Brooks. Have any of you actually watched the Saints play? He's awful. Talented, but dumb as a brick.

I agree. I can't even believe there is discussion on this right now lol.

Not to mention, Garcia knows this offense.

So did Mike McMahon, and he was supposed to be so much better than Koy. You keep on pretending that Garcia's a good QB though.

[Wingspan]

brooks sucks

[BigEd76]

Bad coaching doesn't cause him to make some of the stupid ass throws that he has made. Remember than one against Denver where he threw it with his left hand? He's a moron.

How about the backward pass to Wayne Gandy two years ago in San Diego?